Référence bibliographique [4859]
Eid, Paul. 2003. «Ethnic and Religious Identity Retention Among Second-generation Arab Youths in Montreal (Quebec)». Thèse de doctorat, Toronto, Université de Toronto, Département de sociologie.
Fiche synthèse
1. Objectifs
Intentions :
« This research focuses on the relationship between ethnic and religious identity retention processes among second-generation Christian and Muslim Arab youths attending Cegep in the Greater Montreal area. Special attention will be paid to the influence of three socio-cultural factors on both processes: 1) parental socialization, 2) traditionalism regarding gender relationships, 3) self-experienced discrimation, and perceived stereotyping. » (p. 1)
Questions/Hypothèses :
« 1) The external (or behavioural) aspects of Arab-Canadian youths’ ethnic and religious identities are significantly less developed than their internal (or subjective) aspects. In other terms, Arab adolescents have developed a rather symbolic ethnicity as a result of socio-cultural incorporation.
2) The more the respondents’ parents have attempted to transmit their ethnic identity and culture, the more their children will have maintained their own ethnic identity and culture.
3) The more respondents’ parents have retained their religious identity and culture, the more their children will have maintained their own religious identity and culture.
4) There is a positive correlation between ethnic and religious identity retention processes.
5) The more respondents endorse traditional gender role models, the more they are likely to retain their ethnic identity.
6) The more respondents endorse traditional gender role models, the more they are likely to retain their religious identity.
7) More parental control is exerted on females than on males.
8) Girls more than boys feel they are subjected to excessive parental control.
9) The more youngsters report having personnaly experienced discrimination in Canadian society as Arab-origin individuals, the more they are likely to retain their ethnic and religious identities (question relating to discrimination).
10) The more youngsters consider that the host society harbour negative stereotypes against their ethno-religious group, the more they are likely to retain their ethnic and religious identities (question relating to prejudicial stereotyping). » (p. 63)
2. Méthode
Échantillon/Matériau :
« The target population for this research is Muslim and Christian students of Arab origin [250] from 5 selected Cegeps of the Greater Montreal, aged between 17 and 24 years old, and whose both parents migrated from an Arab country. The sampled Cegeps were selected on the basis of their high concentration of Arab students. The 5 selected institutions are Cegep Saint-Laurent, Cegep Bois-de-Boulogne, Cegep Ahuntsic, Cegep Mont-Morency, and Vanier College. » (p. 64)
Instruments :
« The methods used in this research will be, first, quantitative analysis based on a sample of 250 respondents of Arab origin attending Cegep in Montreal. These respondents were asked to fill out a questionnaire comprised of 85 multiple choice questions. If quantitative methods are of much help to measure the intensity of one’s attachment to any given identity category, they fall short of tapping into the various motives and meanings underlying the actor’s identity choices and strategies. Thus, the quantitative information provided by the questionnaires were complemented by a series of approximately 16 in-depth and non-directive interviews conducted with subjects selected among our 250 respondents. » (p. 64)
Type de traitement des données :
Analyse statistique et analyse de contenu
3. Résumé
« Employing a non-random sample survey and in-depth interview, I explore the relationship between ethnic and religious identity retention among Arab-origin students from five Cegeps in Montreal. Being non-random, this sample is not representative of the whole population of Arab-origin Cegep students in Montreal. Special attention is paid to the influence of three socio-cultural factors: parental socialization, gender-related traditionalism, and perceived discrimination and stereotyping.
I examine how group boundaries among the second generation emerge from reappropriations of pre-fabricated ethnic labels and identities. Although these youths identify strongly with their ethnic culture and community, nonetheless, they fail to show matching levels of enmeshment in ethnic-based socialization networks. While it may be argued that a symbolic ethnicity is well underway among these second-generationers, I discovered that a symbolic religiosity was even more prevalent. Indeed, religion is more experienced by these youths as a group boundary marker, than as a binding frame of religious prescriptions and rituals. In any case, the data strongly suggest that religion and ethnicity are intertwined within these youths’ identity structure. This connection reflects the refocusing of national Great narratives, in the postcolonial Arab world, on religious symbolism and rhetoric.
Female conduct and sexuality also proved to be a primary locus of ethno-religious identity. However, traditional gender relationships come to be highly problematized as part of these youths’ identity building strategies. Furthermore, females are more likely than males to critically engage traditional gender roles.
Also, these Arab youths generally feel well accepted by Canadians in their personal life. However, they often downplay the Arab component of their identity as a way to ward off prejudice and discrimination. As well, there is a strong perception among these youths that Canadian people and media have a very low regard for Arab and/or Muslim culture.
Finally, because Canadians lump all Arab groups together, these second-generationers largely come to identify themselves as Arabs. However, the adoption of transnational Arab identity presupposes the subversion of the Western-made derogatory significations attached to it. Yet, outside labelling exerts ’symbolic violence’ on these youths, which leads some, especially Christians, to reject the Arab label, deemed socially compromising. » (pp. ii-iii)